Talk:Potions

Content vs flask pages
At the moment many of the material pages are named "[material name] flask" and contain duplicated description of how flask works. This is wrong: the materials should have their own pages, with (single) flask page linking all materials commonly found in flasks, not "material flask" pages. Materials can be found outside flasks, for example in Twisty Passages. 178.235.13.44 04:27, 26 October 2019 (UTC)

Flasks that aren't found in game shouldn't be in this list
While all liquids in the game can be collected in a flask, they are already listed in the Materials page so listing them all here is redundant. Besides, it is possible to fill flasks with multiple liquids at the same time; listing all those combinations would be maddening. Additionally, some materials that cannot be collected in flasks can be found in game, specifically powders such as gunpowder and salt; these flasks are much more worthy of being on this list, given how unusual they are.

This page essentially needs to be rewritten
Going off of the above. There should be a flasks page and a materials page, but no [material] flasks pages. The list at the bottom should otherwise only list special flasks that the player can't fill themselves, or ones that act differently when sprayed (cocktails, gunpowder exploding when sprayed, etc). A real pezzo guy (talk) 13:48, 28 December 2019 (UTC)